| Name | Years | Served Under |
| Rev.Francis A. Fitzgerald | 1955-1963 | Pastor, 1955-1963 |
| Rev.Joseph A. Belfiore | 1956-1964 | Fr. Fitzgerald |
| Rev.Gerard J. Sheridan | 1964-1983 | Pastor, 1964-1983 |
| Rev.John Serrano | 1965-1968 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Rocco Gallitelli | 1965-1974 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Michael Hoban | 1968-1971 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Charles Staiger | 1971-1975 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.John Gabriele | 1974-1981 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Charles Fink | 1976-1983 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Santiago Dineros | 1978 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev. Francis Sang | 1978-1972 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Francis Corrao | 1979-1980 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Hector Valenzuela | 1980-1982 | Fr. Sheridan |
| Rev.Raymond Nugent | 1981-1985 | Fr. Sheridan & Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Peter Liu | 1982-1987 | Fr. Sheridan & Msgr. Curley |
| Msgr.Joseph Curley | 1983-2010 | Pastor, 1983-2010 |
| Rev.Warren Gress | 1983-1988 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Barry Mercado | 1985-1987 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Al Rogers | 1987-1994 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Vincent Martega | 1988-1991 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Andrew Nirrengarten | 1988-1993 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Raymond Joseph | 1990-1997 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Larry Duncklee | 1993-1996 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Paul Mijas | 1996-2001 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.William Shean | 1996-2004 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Augustine Kuriapilly | 2001-2002 | Msgr. Curley |
| Rev.Charles Srion | 2002-2011 | Msgr. Curley& Fr. Chris Aridas |
| Rev.Chris Aridas | 2010- | Pastor, 2010-2019. Retired under Fr. Joseph Alenchery |
| Rev. Joseph Alenchery | 2011- | Served with Fr. Chris Aridas; became pastor, 2019 |